Brought to you by the Columbus Bar Association through its division, Columbus Bar Services
Ashley Rutherford Starling

Ashley Rutherford Starling

Ashley Starling is a personal injury attorney focusing on car accidents, trucking accidents, animal attacks, intentional torts, slip and falls/premises liability and other types of civil litigation. Ashley Starling is an experienced litigator whose mission is to help injured victims seek justice and compensation.
Willis & Willis Attorneys
(9 Attorneys)

Injury and Accidents

4635 Trueman Boulevard, Suite 200
Hilliard, OH 43026

12 years

(614) 586-7900

(614) 586-7901

What made you choose your primary specialty focus of law?

I always knew I was meant to help others.  What I love about personal injury is that I am able to guide someone through one of the worst experiences of their lives.  I consider myself just as much a counselor as an attorney, and I take pride in the personal attention I provide to my clients.

What makes your law firm unique?

Our law firm is all about personal service.  We understand the need for client contact, and we try to make that contact as convenient as possible.  If you call in to our office and ask to speak to an attorney, an attorney in our office will be available to speak with you.  If you want to email us, we are available by email. 

Describe your personal interest and hobbies.

I am the current reigning Mrs. Ohio America, and I competed at Mrs. America in Las Vegas, Nevada in September 2015 where I was a semi-finalist. 

I enjoy being active - dancing, lifting weights, and yoga.  You will find me at coffee shops, trying new restaurants, and spending time with friends.

I predominantly spend my time away from work with my family.  My husband Jason and I are both attorneys.  We believe this is likely why our toddler son is such a stellar negotiator. 


Describe your charitable activities.

I am on the Nationwide Children's Hospital Development Board, where I help raise money for research and development through various fundraisers.  I am also a member of the admitting gift cart committee, so I get to drive a cart full of toys through the hospital and give gifts to the admitted patients.  I also had the opportunity to walk with a cancer survivor with the Nellie's Catwalk for Kids (NC4K) fashion show this past year while serving as Mrs. Ohio America. 

Injury and Accidents
  • Accidents
  • Mass Accidents
  • Motor Vehicle Accidents
  • Personal Injury
  • Wrongful Death

Marshall University
B.B.A. Business Management/Economics, 2005

University of Louisville School of Law
J.D. Law, 2008

The Ohio State University, Moritz College of Law
J.D. Law - Visiting Student , 2008

Bar Association Membership

Columbus Bar Association

Court Admissions

Northern District of Ohio
Southern District of Ohio
United States Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals

Bar Admission Date


Licensed In

Ohio (2020), #0084009

Significant Cases

$250,000.00 Settlement - Client was rear-ended on I-71 North.  He suffered sprain/strains and developed severe anxiety and depression resulting from the accident. 

$125,000.00 Pre-litigation Settlement - Client was hit by a vehicle.  She suffered sprain/strains and a fractured hand. 

$94,500.00 Settlement - Client, an Amish gentlemen, was in a buggy.  The buggy was t-boned by a Honda Civic.  He fell onto the pavement and suffered injuries to his spine.  Bills were over $65,000.00 and were reduced to $25,000.00 during the settlement process. 

$100,000.00 Pre-litigation Settlement (Liability and UIM Policy Limits) - Client was injured when he fell off his motorcyle during a collision. He endured a cervical fusion at two levels.  Bills were well over $100,000, and we reduced to only a fraction of the amount owed. 

$110,000.00 Settlement - On behalf of a client that suffered injuries in an elevator downtown when the elevator malfunctioned.  The client endured a hip replacement.  The client had over $65,000.00 in subrogation.  That amount was reduced to less than $8,000.00. 

*The are just representative awards.  The amount of verdicts and settlements is based upon the facts and circumstances of each individual case.

Free Initial Consultation?

I provide a free initial consultation in all cases. 

Typical Retainer Fees

If I take a case for an hourly rate, I request a $5,000.00 retainer to be replenished once the retainer amount hits $1,500.00.  Again, however, all personal injury plaintiff work is done on a contingency fee basis.

Fixed-Price Services and Fees

I take personal injury cases on a contingency fee basis; this means you pay no up-front costs for my services.  I am compensated at the end of the case.  I also front litigation expenses necessary to pursue your cause of action.

Fees by Hourly Rate

I charge $300.00 per hour for hourly rate billings.  However, the vast majority of my work is done on a contingency fee basis.


Back To Search Results